Fireman Adib’s father fails to get AG Tommy Thomas cited for contempt of court…


Lawyers Ambiga Sreenevasan, Zainur Zakaria and Senior Federal Counsel S Narkunavathy represented Thomas, while Mohamed Haniff Khatri Abdullah appeared for Kassim.

V Anbalagan -January 28, 2020 11:00 AM

SHAH ALAM: The High Court here today cleared Attorney-General Tommy Thomas of contempt of court in the inquest proceeding of fireman Muhammad Adib Mohd Kassim last year.

Judicial commissioner Meor Hashimi Abd Hamid said the application by Adib’s father, Mohd Kassim Abdul Hamid, had failed to comply with Order 52 of the High Court rules for non- disclosure of material facts.

“The coroner (Rofiah Mohamad) also failed to consider some of the matters raised by the AG and his officer (Hamdan Hamzah) in their affidavits,” he said in allowing Thomas’ appeal.

Meor Hashimi said the coroner had also taken into account matters outside the ambit of the contempt application.

However, he also ruled that the coroner had jurisdiction to hear the complaint against Thomas for showing disrespect to the court.

Lawyers Ambiga Sreenevasan, Zainur Zakaria and Senior Federal Counsel S Narkunavathy represented Thomas, while Mohamed Haniff Khatri Abdullah appeared for Kassim.

On July 16, Kassim filed an ex parte application for a committal order against Thomas for allegedly insulting the court through the filing of an affidavit by the Attorney-General’s Chambers on April 3, which indicated that Adib’s death was not caused by injuries sustained.

The affidavit was filed while the inquest into Adib’s death was underway.

On Aug 28, Rofiah allowed Kassim’s application to initiate committal proceedings against Thomas for contempt in the inquest into his son’s death.

Rofiah said she came to the conclusion after studying the documents and affidavits submitted by both parties, and Kassim had proven a prima facie case against Thomas.

On Sept 27, Rofiah ruled that “more than two unidentified persons” had killed Adib, who died after succumbing to injuries he sustained when he was despatched to the scene of a riot outside the Sri Maha Mariamman temple in November 2018

Adib, 24, a member of the Subang Jaya Fire and Rescue Department, was seriously injured in the riot at the temple in USJ 25, Subang Jaya, on Nov 27, 2018 and died on Dec 17 the same year at the National Heart Institute.


24 July 2019

Free Malaysia Today @fmtoday

AG denies interrupting Adib inquest

SHAH ALAM: Attorney-General (AG) Tommy Thomas has denied claims by Muhammad Adib Mohd Kassim’s family that he interrupted the proceedings of the inquest into the fireman’s death.

He said the family’s allegations were levelled against him after his media statement on May 28 stating that Syazlin Mansor, the lawyer representing the housing and local government ministry at the time, was in a “conflicted position” and had contradicted the position of the deputy public prosecutors in the proceedings.

In an affidavit filed in objection to the contempt proceeding sought against him, he said he had issued the statement to clarify the situation and to clear any confusion about Syazlin’s withdrawal from the inquest proceedings.

Adib’s father Mohd Kassim Abdul Hamid had sought to cite Thomas for contempt, accusing the AG of interfering in the inquest into his son’s death.

Kassim also claimed that Thomas had attempted to stop Syazlin from exercising her duty as a lawyer.

Syazlin withdrew from representing the ministry as well as Adib’s family after Thomas told the ministry to revoke her appointment.

She later agreed to return as the family’s lawyer after Kassim asked her to stay.

In his affidavit, Thomas said Syazlin’s “sudden withdrawal” had caused much confusion and speculation in the Coroner’s Court as well as among the public.

The AG also denied instructing his former deputy public prosecutor, Hamdan Hamzah, to file an affidavit for an appeal issued in relation to the inquest.

“I never met Hamdan, and any affidavit affirmed by him is within his scope of work,” he said.

“I did not give instructions as to the filing or contents of his affidavit.”

In his affidavit for an appeal by the Sri Maha Mariamman temple task force to participate in the inquest, Hamdan said Adib was not beaten by anyone during the temple riot on Nov 27 last year.

Hamdan, who left the civil service and is now a lawyer, filed his affidavit along with Thomas.

He denied attempting to interrupt the proceedings when filing his affidavit to object to the task force’s appeal.

The Coroner’s Court set Aug 9 to hear two preliminary issues over the filing of contempt proceedings against the AG.

Lawyer Haniff Khatri Abdulla, acting for Adib’s family, told coroner Rofiah Mohamad that they wanted to resolve two issues before the court could hear their application to obtain leave to initiate the contempt proceedings.

“The two issues are whether the Attorney-General’s Chambers (AGC) could be heard at the leave stage when the father, as an applicant, sought to initiate the committal proceeding against the government’s legal adviser, as well as whether the court can entertain affidavits filed by the AG himself and another during the leave stage,” he said.

Senior federal counsel S Narkunavathy, representing the AGC, raised no objection to the court sorting out the preliminary issues first.

Rofiah then told Haniff and Narkunavathy to file their written submissions on the two issues by Aug 5.

AG denies interrupting Adib inquest


This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s